0.1 ng TEQ/Nm³ is achievable: dioxin removal technology routes compared

The 0.1 ng TEQ/Nm³ figure is not a wet-only result and not a property of any one device. It is a system result — combustion, cooling, dust removal, and carbon or catalytic conversion — measured on a stated basis, and the route you choose decides what evidence and what budget are needed.

An incinerator line with cyclone and wet scrubber tower
Incineration & flue gas
On this page

Short answer: 0.1 is achievable — but not by every configuration

Yes. A waste incinerator can hold 0.1 ng TEQ/Nm³, and the figure is not reserved for a wet scrubber. EU reference data record dry, fixed-bed and catalytic systems meeting it, and the limit is a stack concentration, not a technology. No single dioxin removal technology proves a configuration: the route, evidence and measurement basis decide whether 0.1 is real.

0.1 ng TEQ/Nm³ is achievable by dry, wet and catalytic routes, but not by every configuration. A claim is only as strong as its evidence: the stages in the train, the test behind the figure, and the basis stated.
  • Route: destruction, re-formation control, and capture or conversion are different jobs, and a train must cover all three.
  • Evidence: a published result shows the route works, not that a supplier builds it.
  • Basis: 0.1 is incomplete without the sampling period, oxygen basis and TEQ scheme.

Three jobs, not three technologies: destroy, prevent re-formation, capture or convert

PCDD/F control is not a choice of three technologies. Every route must destroy what is present, keep the gas out of the band where more forms, and capture or convert what remains. Table 1 separates those jobs.

Wide table: scroll sideways to see every column.

StageWhat it does to PCDD/FDestroys?Boundary that decides performance
Combustion and secondary chamberOxidises PCDD/F and precursorsYesTemperature, time, turbulence, oxygen and steady load together
Rapid coolingShortens time in the re-formation windowNo (prevents)Does not remove what has formed; rate and time matter
Carbon injection + bag filterAdsorbs gas-phase PCDD/FNo (transfers)Carbon type, dose, mixing, temperature and cake decide; spent carbon is waste
Fixed carbon bedAdsorbs PCDD/F through a bedNo (transfers)Pressure drop, footprint, bed temperature, fire risk
Catalytic filter bagFilters dust and oxidises gas-phase PCDD/FYesTemperature window; does not control mercury
Wet scrubber + carbonCools, removes acid gas; carbon adsorbsNo (mainly transfers)Water alone is unreliable; manage wastewater and memory effect

Table 1: Dioxin control stages by job, not by route name.

Each route can reach 0.1; the stages, residues and evidence differ.

The part every route shares: combustion and cooling

No downstream route repairs combustion that is not working. The chamber destroys what is present, and cooling takes the gas out of the band where new PCDD/F form on fly ash; those duties are covered in why incinerators run at 850 °C for two seconds and dioxin formation after the furnace.

EU BAT 30(d) in Decision (EU) 2019/2010 requires rapid cooling from above 400 °C to below 250 °C before dust abatement, to limit de novo synthesis; it sets the cooling design direction, not a probe setpoint.

The dry route: what DSI does and does not do

Dry sorbent injection (DSI) is hydrated lime or another alkaline sorbent dosed to neutralise acid gases. It is an acid-gas step, not a dioxin removal technology on its own. Dioxin removal from flue gas in a dry train comes from activated carbon injection plus a bag filter, or a fixed carbon bed.

A dry train can still meet 0.1. The EU Waste Incineration BREF (2019, JRC118637) records at p.220, Table 3.9, a small clinical-waste line with a bag filter plus dry calcium hydroxide and activated carbon injection: maximum 0.02, mean 0.006 ng I-TEQ/Nm³ in the UK14.1 data. These are published international results, not tests of our equipment.

At p.416 carbon injection at 0.5–2 kg/t, usually with a bag filter, gives below 0.06 ng I-TEQ/Nm³; that dose is a municipal-waste context, not a small-unit setpoint.

A dry train holds 0.1 only when:

  • Cooling takes the gas out of the formation window before the filter.
  • The filter inlet temperature suits the bag and suppresses de novo synthesis.
  • Carbon type, dose and mixing are right.
  • Residence time ahead of the filter is enough, and injection is continuous.
  • The filter cake is cleaned so that it acts as a bed, not a bypass.
  • Start-up, shutdown and load changes are covered, and the 0.1 basis is stated.

Miss one and the route is still dry, but the result is not the published result.

The wet route: why the scrubber is not the dioxin stage

The scrubber is not the dioxin stage. BREF p.511 states that PCDD/F have very low solubility in water, so a wet scrubber does not significantly or reliably remove them; most of what it removes is the dust that carries them. BAT 30(i) therefore requires a carbon sorbent or impregnated packing.

The wet train cools the gas, removes acid gases and captures particulate. Whether it holds a dioxin figure depends on dust removal and the carbon stage, not the water; its liquid circuit must be managed for the memory effect.

Semi-dry is not waterless: the BREF definition includes lime slurry, aqueous solution, or dry powder with separate water injection.

Catalytic filter bags vs activated carbon

Catalytic filter bag and activated carbon are a choice between conversion and transfer. Carbon adsorbs gas-phase PCDD/F and the bag retains the spent carbon, so the molecules leave in dioxin-bearing ash and carbon. A catalytic filter bag filters dust and oxidises gas-phase PCDD/F.

BREF p.415–416, Table 4.38, gives a catalytic filter bag over 21 months at 0.002–0.023 ng TEQ/Nm³ and 99.6–99.9% removal; p.417 gives a fixed carbon bed below 0.03 ng I-TEQ/Nm³. Hsu et al. (Waste Management 46, 2015, DOI 10.1016/j.wasman.2015.09.002) found both routes able to meet 0.1, with adsorption transferring PCDD/F to fly ash and catalytic destruction leaving lower-TEQ ash.

A catalytic filter has a temperature window and a higher capital cost, and it does not control mercury; carbon injection is simpler but consumable.

SCR: a NOx stage is not automatically a dioxin guarantee

SCR can lower PCDD/F while reducing NOx, but not automatically. Goemans et al. (Chemosphere 54, 2004, DOI 10.1016/S0045-6535(03)00255-8) reported a specific low-dust SCR at a typical 0.001 ng TEQ/Nm³; Chang et al. (Chemosphere 66, 2007, DOI 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2006.06.020) reported an SCR at about 220 °C still at 0.728 ng TEQ/Nm³. Catalyst, inlet and design make the difference.

The EU BAT conclusions list SCR among the techniques to consider, not as a substitute for the other PCDD/F controls. An SCR chosen only for NOx is not the dioxin guarantee until its PCDD/F performance is stated; the NOx side is in SNCR vs SCR for a small incinerator.

Route comparison table

Table 2 compares the routes on evidence, residue and failure mode.

Wide table: scroll sideways to see every column.

RouteWhat it doesPublished evidence (not our test)Residue and consumableTypical failure mode
Dry: DSI + carbon + bag filterNeutralises acid gas; carbon adsorbs; bag retains carbonBREF p.220: max 0.02, mean 0.006 ng I-TEQ/Nm³; p.416: 0.5–2 kg/t below 0.06 (MSWI)Spent carbon, filter ashDSI treated as the dioxin stage
Fixed carbon bedAdsorbs PCDD/FBREF p.417: below 0.03Spent carbonBed temperature, pressure drop, fire
Wet scrubber + carbonCools, removes acid gas; carbon adsorbsBREF p.511: water unreliable; BAT 30(i) needs carbonWastewater, spent carbonMemory effect; untreated wastewater
Catalytic filter bagFilters dust and oxidises PCDD/FBREF Table 4.38: 0.002–0.023, 99.6–99.9%Spent catalyst filterTemperature window; mercury uncontrolled
SCR sized for the dutyReduces NOx, can lower PCDD/FGoemans 2004: 0.001 typical; Chang 2007: 0.728 counterexampleSpent catalystAssumed guarantee without evidence

Table 2: Routes compared on evidence, residue and failure mode.

The routes reach the same limit by different means and leave different problems behind.

What 0.1 means at acceptance

A stack figure is a measurement result; the conditions are part of the requirement. IED 2010/75/EU, Annex VI, Part 3, point 1.4, sets 0.1 ng/Nm³ over a 6–8 hour sample, with TEQ under the prescribed rules; the general provisions state 273.15 K, 101.3 kPa, dry gas and 11% oxygen.

Wide table: scroll sideways to see every column.

ItemWhat it fixesWhy it changes the number
Sampling period6–8 hours (IED Annex VI)A grab sample is not the same mean
Oxygen basis11% O₂, dry gas (IED)A different basis is a different number
Dry or wet gasDry gas (IED)Moisture must be removed first
TEQ schemeI-TEQ or WHO-TEQ, as statedSchemes weight congeners differently
BAT-AEL vs legal limitEU 2019/2010 Table 7: new <0.01–0.04, existing <0.01–0.06 ng I-TEQ/Nm³An associated level, not a rewrite of 0.1

Table 3: The basis that has to travel with a 0.1 figure.

The legal limit and BAT-AEL answer different questions; a contract should state which is warranted.

The budget boundary: what the price difference is made of

A dry and a wet quotation differ by more than the furnace:

  • Cooling: a quench, a waste-heat boiler, or a longer duct with a different profile.
  • Reagent and carbon: storage, dosing, mixing and continuous consumption.
  • Filtration: an ordinary bag filter, a catalytic bag, or a fixed carbon bed.
  • Wet train: scrubber, pumps, corrosion protection, wastewater treatment and memory-effect management.
  • Catalyst, residue and testing: SCR catalyst, spent carbon, ash and catalyst disposal, sampling and acceptance.

A budget that covers the furnace but not the full train is not a budget for 0.1.

What we publish for our configurations — and what it is not

For our CXMWI medical-waste series we publish three design values on a dry-gas, 11% oxygen basis: A ≤0.8, B ≤0.5 and C ≤0.1 ng TEQ/Nm³. C is the 0.1 design configuration; A is not. These are design values, not third-party test results and not a guarantee; what a site reaches depends on the configuration, project conditions and the post-installation test arranged by the site.

That statement does not say that a dry configuration of ours reaches 0.1 or that any unit has been tested to it. The design values are in the emissions and process parameters chart, and national limits are in the medical-waste incinerator emission limits lookup.

Questions to put to any supplier

These questions turn the comparison into a specification:

  • 1. Which stages are in the train, and which one is claimed to control PCDD/F?
  • 2. Is the dioxin stage carbon adsorption, catalytic conversion, or both?
  • 3. What published evidence supports the route, on a comparable waste and scale?
  • 4. Is the 0.1 figure a design value, a guarantee, or a test result?
  • 5. On what sampling period, oxygen basis and TEQ scheme is it stated?
  • 6. What are the filter inlet temperature, carbon dose and residence time?
  • 7. What residue does the route produce, and where does it go?
  • 8. If wet or catalytic, how are wastewater, memory effect and mercury handled?

Briefly, 0.1 ng TEQ/Nm³ is achievable and does not belong to one route; it follows from a complete train, an evidence trail and an acceptance basis that match the number. When you enquire, put the waste type, throughput in kg/h, daily operating hours, target value with its basis, and the water supply and wastewater conditions in the message. Use the contact page to start.

Tell us what the site has to treat.

Contact details
Waste incineration