On this page
- Twelve questions, because a shortlist hides its differences
- The twelve questions and the answer standard
- Is it a sewage treatment plant manufacturer or a trader?
- Factory evidence a wastewater treatment plant manufacturer can produce
- What should travel with the offer
- Answers that should slow the comparison down
- The same twelve questions, asked of us
- How to score the answers
Twelve questions, because a shortlist hides its differences
Comparing wastewater treatment equipment suppliers on price alone assumes that the offers describe the same plant. They rarely do. One offer is for a packaged unit built in a workshop; another is a trading company's assembly of bought-in parts; a third is a process design with the equipment still to be sourced. The twelve questions below are the ones that separate those cases before a purchase order does.
Each question comes with the standard a qualified answer has to meet. The standard is deliberately about evidence rather than about claims: a document, a photograph taken at the supplier's own works, a test record, or a named person who will sign the figure. Treat any figure in this article as a starting method rather than as a specification for your project.
The twelve questions and the answer standard
Use the table as the agenda for a technical meeting, not as a form to be emailed. The answers that matter are the ones a supplier can produce while you are looking at them.
Wide table: scroll sideways to see every column.
| Question | What a qualified answer has to contain |
|---|---|
| Who manufactures the main tank or vessel? | The works address, and evidence that the shell, partitions and reinforcement are made there: a works photograph of the unit in progress, a welding procedure specification and the welder qualification records behind it. |
| Are you the manufacturer or a trading company? | A direct answer, with the legal name on the business licence matching the name on the offer, and the scope of that licence covering environmental equipment manufacture rather than only trading. |
| Which process train are you offering, and why that one? | The train written stage by stage, with the design flow, the organic load and the discharge grade it is sized against, and the reason the alternatives were set aside. |
| What is the design flow, and what peak factor is applied? | An average daily flow, the peak factor with its source, and whether the tank is sized on average or on peak flow. |
| What influent quality is the design based on? | Measured data where it exists; otherwise a named design range rather than a single number, with the sampling plan that will confirm it. |
| Which discharge standard and grade apply? | The standard number, the grade and the parameter values, including the temperature rule where an ammonia limit carries one. |
| What are the dimensions, mass and shipping envelope? | A dimensioned drawing, the mass of each piece, and the container or break-bulk route proposed, checked against the internal width of the container. |
| What is the installed power and the utility schedule? | Connected load, voltage and frequency, wash-water demand, polymer consumption per tonne of dry solids, and compressed air where it is used. |
| Which components are bought in, and from where? | Blowers, membranes, instruments, valves and the control PLC named by maker and model, with the warranty that passes through to the buyer. |
| What testing is done before shipment? | The factory acceptance test procedure, the records it produces, and the buyer's right to witness the test. |
| What is in the scope, and what is excluded? | A written split between factory supply, site works and buyer supply: foundations, inlet and outlet piping, power cable, water, unloading and commissioning. |
| Who commissions, trains and supports the plant after start-up? | The name and location of the engineer who will attend, the commissioning sequence, the training days, the spare parts list and the response path for a fault. |
Twelve questions and the evidence a qualified answer has to produce.
Two answers are worth more than the rest. The factory evidence in the first two rows decides what kind of company is being dealt with, and the scope split in row eleven decides what the price actually covers. A supplier that answers the other ten well and these two vaguely has left the two commercial risks untouched.
Is it a sewage treatment plant manufacturer or a trader?
The question is not a test of virtue. A company that assembles bought-in equipment can be the right partner for a small plant, and a factory can be the wrong one for a process it does not run. What matters is that the buyer knows which is in front of them, because the two carry different risk.
- A sewage treatment plant manufacturer can show the unit being built: the plate rolled, the tank welded, the frame painted, the cabinet wired, at an address that appears on the business licence.
- A wastewater treatment plant supplier without its own works will usually name the factory it buys from. That is a usable answer, provided the name is given and the scope line on the factory certificate is read.
- A wastewater treatment plant manufacturer that also designs the process holds the sizing calculation and the performance figure itself, rather than passing both back to a third party.
- A wastewater treatment plant supplier that will not name the factory, or names a different one on each enquiry, has removed the buyer's ability to check anything.
Factory evidence a wastewater treatment plant manufacturer can produce
A works visit answers more than a brochure, but it is not always possible before a shortlist is cut. The following can be produced remotely and checked in an afternoon.
- Business licence with the legal name, the registered address, the date of establishment and the scope of business.
- Certificates with the scope line read in full: an ISO 9001 certificate that covers sales says something different from one that covers design and manufacture.
- Photographs of the actual unit in progress, with the project reference visible, rather than a gallery of finished machines.
- Welding procedure specifications and welder qualification records for pressure-retaining parts.
- A factory acceptance test record from a previous unit of the same model, with the measured values left in.
- The spare parts list with part numbers, and the lead time quoted for each item.
What should travel with the offer
The documents below turn a price into a comparable offer. Ask for them in the same format from every candidate, and the comparison stops being a reading exercise.
- A datasheet with the model, the duty point and the guarantee basis, not a catalogue page covering a range.
- A process flow diagram and the mass balance, including the sludge and return-liquor streams.
- A utility schedule: power, wash water, polymer, compressed air and chemicals, each in the unit the site buys it in.
- A general arrangement drawing with dimensions, masses and lifting points.
- The scope split and the exclusion list, in writing.
- A commissioning plan with the tests, the acceptance criteria and the party that signs each one.
- The operation and maintenance manual in the language the operators read, and the training plan that goes with it.
- The warranty terms, including what is excluded and how a claim is raised.
Answers that should slow the comparison down
Some answers are not wrong in themselves, but they remove the buyer's ability to check the offer. Each of the following is a reason to ask a second question before the price is compared.
- A capacity quoted without a design flow, an influent quality and a discharge grade. The number cannot be checked because the duty behind it is missing.
- A model described as standard when the site has a non-standard power supply, climate or discharge limit.
- A guarantee of effluent quality with no statement of the influent it is guaranteed against.
- Bought-in components left unnamed, so that the buyer cannot compare the membrane, the blower or the instrument.
- A price with no exclusion list. The missing items reappear later as variations.
- Payment requested to an account that does not match the contracting entity.
- A reference list that names projects but gives no process, capacity or measured result, and no contact who will discuss them.
The same twelve questions, asked of us
A checklist is only credible if it is applied to the writer. Taking the table in order, the manufacturing evidence, the certificates, the testing records, the component list, the scope split and the commissioning plan are available for a project, and the answers are given against the duty in hand rather than from a general sheet.
One row is not yet at the standard we set. Our published case references do not currently carry the measured influent and effluent data for each project. The projects exist and the equipment is in service, but a reader cannot yet check the water quality result behind each reference. We treat that as an open item, and the honest answer for now is that the data has to be assembled project by project from the operating records rather than presented as a composite figure.
That admission is the reason to write the checklist down. A supplier that claims a perfect score on all twelve rows, with no open item anywhere, is either much better than the rest of the market or has not read its own records.
How to score the answers
A simple three-level score is enough, and it keeps the comparison from turning into an impression.
- Documented: the evidence is in hand and can be checked by a third party.
- Promised: the supplier states the answer but has not produced the document yet. Record the date it was promised.
- Evaded: the question was answered with a different question, or the document was refused.
Weight the first two rows of the table and the scope split as pass or fail. A candidate that cannot evidence the factory, or will not state what the price excludes, is not made safer by scoring well on the rest. The twelve questions are the same ones we answer for a project, confirmed with the factory for your water quality and flow.

